In modern society, masculinity is often defined through narrow and rigid expectations, influencing how men should behave, think, and feel. These societal expectations of masculinity, often referred to as “traditional masculinity,” emphasize traits such as emotional stoicism, independence, aggression, dominance, and self-reliance. While these ideals may have historical and cultural significance, they can also contribute to harmful outcomes for men’s mental health, leading to issues such as depression, anxiety, and substance abuse. Men are often socialized to suppress vulnerability, avoid seeking help, and adhere to a hyper-masculine identity that ultimately diminishes their emotional well-being.
This paper explores how societal expectations of masculinity shape men’s mental health, analyzing the direct and indirect ways that these cultural norms contribute to mental health issues. By examining the psychological and sociocultural effects of masculinity, we can better understand why men may struggle with emotional distress and develop mental health conditions. Furthermore, understanding the intersections between masculinity and mental health can offer insight into the strategies that may help alleviate these challenges and promote healthier societal views of masculinity.
Understanding Masculinity and Mental Health
To grasp the full extent of how societal expectations of masculinity affect mental health, it is crucial to first examine the relationship between masculinity and mental health. Gender norms and stereotypes are deeply ingrained in society, and men are often taught from a young age to embody qualities associated with masculinity, such as strength, power, control, and emotional detachment.
Masculinity and Emotional Expression
One of the most significant ways that masculinity influences mental health is through emotional expression. The expectation for men to suppress emotions—especially those perceived as “weak” or “feminine,” such as sadness, fear, or vulnerability—can have detrimental effects on mental health. Research shows that men are less likely than women to seek emotional support, express their feelings, or acknowledge mental health issues like depression and anxiety. This emotional repression, referred to as “normative male alexithymia,” can lead to a buildup of emotional distress, contributing to mental health disorders.
Men are often socialized to internalize emotional struggles, with the cultural message being that expressing emotion is a sign of weakness or failure. In turn, men may experience feelings of isolation or inadequacy when they cannot meet these expectations. This internal conflict can exacerbate mental health challenges and create barriers to seeking help, further deepening their emotional struggles.
Masculine Norms and Self-Worth
Self-worth is another area where societal expectations of masculinity have a direct impact on men’s mental health. Traditional masculinity often links a man’s value to external achievements, such as career success, financial stability, and the ability to be a provider. This connection between masculinity and material success can place intense pressure on men, leaving them feeling inadequate if they fail to meet these expectations.
For many men, failure to live up to societal ideals of masculinity can lead to self-criticism, low self-esteem, and a sense of inadequacy. These feelings are strongly associated with mental health conditions like depression. Men who place their worth on external achievements may also struggle with anxiety, as they constantly worry about falling short of expectations. Over time, the inability to meet these pressures can lead to chronic emotional distress and a sense of hopelessness.
Depression Among Men
Depression is one of the most common mental health disorders affecting men, but it is often underdiagnosed and undertreated due to the societal stigma surrounding mental health and masculinity. The traditional masculine ideals discourage men from acknowledging their emotional struggles, which leads to a greater reluctance to seek professional help or discuss their mental health with others.
The Mask of Masculinity
The “mask of masculinity” is a concept introduced by sociologist and psychologist Dr. Ronald F. Levant, which refers to the ways in which men present themselves in a socially acceptable manner, often suppressing their true feelings and struggles in the process. This mask is a coping mechanism to conform to societal expectations and avoid the perceived stigma of vulnerability or emotional weakness. However, this mask can also perpetuate mental health issues, particularly depression.
Men who hide their depressive symptoms behind a mask of stoicism and strength may experience delayed or missed diagnoses, which can exacerbate the severity of the condition. Furthermore, the emotional suppression associated with the mask of masculinity can lead to an accumulation of stress and frustration, which contributes to deeper feelings of hopelessness. Men may also struggle to find an outlet for their emotions, increasing the likelihood of self-destructive behaviors such as substance abuse.
Risk Factors for Depression in Men
Several factors make men particularly vulnerable to depression, including the emphasis on self-reliance and the stigma surrounding vulnerability. Research shows that men who adhere more strictly to traditional masculine norms are at higher risk of experiencing depressive symptoms. Moreover, men are less likely to seek professional treatment for depression due to concerns about appearing weak or inadequate. These cultural barriers result in delayed interventions, which can worsen the condition over time.
Anxiety in Men
Anxiety is another mental health condition that disproportionately affects men, although it often manifests in different ways than it does in women. The pressure to conform to masculine norms can create feelings of anxiety and fear of failure, especially when men feel that they are not living up to societal expectations.
Hypermasculinity and Anxiety
Hypermasculinity—the exaggerated adherence to traditional masculine ideals—has been linked to higher levels of anxiety in men. Men who adhere to these rigid norms may feel constant pressure to be dominant, successful, and emotionally controlled. The inability to achieve these ideals can lead to feelings of inadequacy, anxiety, and even panic attacks. The constant need to prove oneself can lead to an overwhelming sense of fear and anxiety about personal and professional failure.
Additionally, anxiety can stem from the fear of being judged or labeled as weak. For men who fear being perceived as less masculine, the prospect of showing vulnerability or expressing emotional distress becomes a source of anxiety. The result is often a cycle of increasing emotional strain and avoidance behaviors, which prevent men from addressing their mental health concerns.
Substance Abuse Among Men
Substance abuse is a significant issue among men, and societal expectations of masculinity play a key role in the development and maintenance of this behavior. Men are more likely to engage in high-risk behaviors such as excessive drinking, drug use, and other forms of substance abuse as a way to cope with stress, emotional pain, and societal pressures.
Masculinity and Risk-Taking Behavior
Traditional masculinity often promotes risk-taking behaviors, such as drinking alcohol, smoking, and engaging in reckless activities. These behaviors are sometimes perceived as signs of strength, independence, or resilience. As a result, men may be more likely to turn to substances as a way to cope with emotional distress, feelings of inadequacy, or anxiety. These behaviors may initially provide temporary relief, but they often worsen mental health in the long term by masking underlying issues and creating additional physical and psychological problems.
Substance abuse among men is often normalized in social contexts, such as among male friends or in certain professional or cultural environments. The normalization of risky behaviors creates an environment where men may feel compelled to engage in substance abuse as part of their masculine identity. Over time, this can lead to a cycle of addiction, further isolating men from seeking help and exacerbating their mental health struggles.
The Role of Trauma and Substance Abuse
Substance abuse is often linked to trauma, and many men turn to drugs or alcohol to numb emotional pain or cope with past trauma. The social expectation that men should not express vulnerability makes it difficult for them to seek help or talk about traumatic experiences. Instead, many men resort to substance use as a coping mechanism. Whether stemming from childhood abuse, military service, or other sources of trauma, the unaddressed pain can manifest in substance abuse as men try to block out or escape their emotional struggles.
Breaking the Cycle: Challenging Societal Expectations of Masculinity
While societal expectations of masculinity continue to contribute to mental health issues, there is hope for change. Challenging these norms and promoting healthier, more flexible models of masculinity can reduce the negative effects on men’s mental health.
Redefining Masculinity
One of the most effective ways to address the mental health crisis among men is to redefine masculinity. By encouraging men to embrace a broader range of emotions and traits—such as vulnerability, empathy, and cooperation—society can create an environment where men feel more comfortable expressing their true selves without fear of judgment. This shift requires cultural change at multiple levels, including education, media representation, and public policy.
Promoting alternative models of masculinity that focus on emotional well-being, mental health awareness, and relational intimacy can reduce the stigma around seeking help. This includes encouraging men to express their emotions, ask for support, and engage in self-care practices without the fear of being labeled as weak or feminine.
Supporting Mental Health and Substance Abuse Treatment
Another critical aspect of breaking the cycle is providing men with the support they need to manage mental health challenges and substance abuse. Mental health professionals and support groups can offer men a safe space to discuss their struggles and receive guidance on how to address them. Community-based programs that emphasize emotional well-being and peer support are particularly beneficial, as they provide men with a sense of connection and understanding.
Moreover, it is essential for healthcare systems to create environments that are welcoming and nonjudgmental, where men can receive mental health care without fear of stigma. Treatment should focus on not only managing symptoms of depression, anxiety, and substance abuse, but also addressing the underlying societal pressures that contribute to these issues.
Impact of Societal Expectations of Masculinity on Society as a Whole and Emotional Impacts
The societal expectations of masculinity have a far-reaching impact not only on men themselves but also on society at large. These cultural norms affect relationships, family dynamics, workplace environments, and the broader social structure. The emotional impacts of these expectations are deeply intertwined with individual well-being, contributing to collective emotional health and influencing social behaviors and values.
Impact on Society as a Whole
Reinforcement of Gender Inequality
Societal expectations of masculinity often reinforce traditional gender roles, leading to an imbalance of power between men and women. Men are often socialized to be dominant, assertive, and in control, while women are traditionally expected to be passive, nurturing, and supportive. These roles can perpetuate inequality in various social contexts, such as the workplace, political systems, and household dynamics.
This gender inequality is not only harmful to women but also limits men in expressing their full range of emotions and behaviors. When men are pressured to conform to rigid masculine norms, they may experience frustration or resentment, leading to a cycle of reinforcing harmful stereotypes. For example, men may feel that they must constantly prove their worth in competitive work environments, which can discourage collaboration and empathy, thus reducing the collective emotional intelligence of society as a whole.
Normalization of Violence and Aggression
Traditional masculine norms often emphasize aggression, dominance, and physical toughness, which can contribute to the normalization of violence in society. Men who internalize these traits may be more prone to aggressive behaviors, whether in personal relationships, at work, or in broader societal contexts. This can lead to higher rates of domestic violence, bullying, physical altercations, and even systemic violence such as war and conflict.
Additionally, the expectation for men to resolve conflicts through aggression or dominance may discourage the development of healthier communication skills, making it harder for individuals to express themselves constructively and engage in peaceful problem-solving. Over time, this normalization of violence becomes ingrained in society, leading to cultural acceptance of harmful behaviors and escalating conflicts.
Hindrance to Progress in Mental Health Awareness
The reluctance of men to discuss their emotional struggles due to the stigma surrounding masculinity creates a significant barrier to progress in mental health awareness. The societal expectation that men should be stoic and self-reliant often leads to the underreporting of mental health issues such as depression, anxiety, and suicidal thoughts among men. This, in turn, hinders the overall understanding of mental health needs and limits the availability of resources tailored to men.
When men are not encouraged to openly address their emotional difficulties, society as a whole misses the opportunity to provide early interventions and mental health support. Consequently, the wider societal conversation about mental health remains unbalanced and incomplete, affecting the collective well-being of the population. Moreover, mental health crises like suicide are disproportionately high among men, with societal expectations of masculinity playing a key role in the lack of resources, awareness, and care.
Impact on Family and Relationship Dynamics
Societal expectations of masculinity also affect relationships and family dynamics. In many cultures, men are expected to be the primary breadwinners and protectors of their families. This role can lead to immense stress and a skewed distribution of emotional labor within families, with men feeling pressured to provide for and protect their loved ones while suppressing their own emotional needs.
This pressure can create a disconnect in family relationships. Men may struggle to express vulnerability or engage in emotionally supportive behaviors, which can result in emotional distance between partners and between fathers and children. The emotional barriers that arise from traditional masculinity can hinder the development of healthy, communicative, and emotionally connected relationships, both within families and in wider social interactions.
Workplace and Economic Implications
In the workplace, the societal expectation that men should be assertive, ambitious, and career-focused often leads to a competitive, high-pressure environment. Men may internalize these expectations, working long hours or pursuing high-stress jobs to meet the demands of their gender role. This can contribute to burnout, job dissatisfaction, and poor mental health.
Furthermore, when men are discouraged from showing vulnerability or asking for help in professional settings, it can create a toxic work culture where emotional intelligence and collaboration are undervalued. A lack of emotional openness in the workplace can impede teamwork, communication, and overall job satisfaction. Ultimately, this can lead to higher turnover rates, workplace dysfunction, and a lack of productivity, which has broad economic consequences for businesses and the economy.
Emotional Impacts on Men
Emotional Repression and Isolation
One of the most profound emotional impacts of societal expectations of masculinity is emotional repression. Men are often socialized to suppress emotions like sadness, fear, and vulnerability, and they are taught to “tough it out” in the face of challenges. This emotional repression can lead to a deep sense of isolation, as men struggle to express their feelings or seek support from others.
Over time, this emotional suppression can contribute to loneliness, as men may feel disconnected from their own emotional experiences and from others. The inability to share personal struggles or express vulnerability creates a sense of alienation, which can be exacerbated by the fear of being judged or seen as weak. This isolation is one of the key factors that contribute to the higher rates of depression, anxiety, and even suicide among men.
Increased Stress and Anxiety
The pressure to conform to societal expectations of masculinity can create a constant sense of stress and anxiety. Men may feel compelled to maintain a façade of strength and self-sufficiency, even in the face of personal or professional difficulties. The fear of failure or inadequacy, coupled with the pressure to be a provider and protector, can lead to chronic anxiety.
Additionally, the fear of being judged for expressing emotions or asking for help may create a sense of constant self-monitoring, where men feel they must constantly prove their worth and maintain control. This high level of stress can have both immediate and long-term emotional impacts, leading to feelings of helplessness, exhaustion, and emotional numbness.
Increased Risk of Depression and Suicide
The societal expectation for men to maintain an emotional “mask” can directly contribute to depression. Men who suppress their feelings may begin to feel overwhelmed by the weight of their emotional distress, leading to negative thought patterns, feelings of hopelessness, and depressive symptoms. The belief that they should handle everything on their own and that seeking help is a sign of weakness can prevent men from reaching out for support.
Tragically, this emotional isolation and inability to seek help contribute to the alarmingly high rates of suicide among men. Studies show that men are more likely to die by suicide than women, in large part due to the stigma surrounding mental health and the cultural expectation to remain emotionally strong. Depression among men is often masked by external signs such as irritability or aggression, which further complicates diagnosis and treatment.
Substance Abuse as a Coping Mechanism
Faced with the emotional toll of societal expectations, many men turn to substances as a way to cope with the emotional pain of depression, anxiety, and stress. Alcohol and drug use are often socially accepted outlets for men, especially in contexts where the expression of vulnerability is discouraged. Substance abuse can act as a temporary escape from the emotional repression men experience, but it ultimately exacerbates mental health issues.
The use of substances as a coping mechanism can lead to addiction, which compounds emotional distress and creates a vicious cycle. Rather than addressing the root causes of emotional pain, men may continue to turn to substances to numb their feelings, making it harder to break free from the emotional burden of societal expectations.
Hindered Emotional Intelligence and Relationship Strain
The suppression of emotions and failure to express vulnerability can hinder the development of emotional intelligence in men. Emotional intelligence—the ability to recognize, understand, and manage one’s emotions as well as the emotions of others—is crucial for building healthy relationships and social connections. Men who are socialized to suppress emotions may struggle with empathy, communication, and conflict resolution, which can lead to strained relationships with family, friends, and partners.
The inability to engage in open, emotionally honest communication can lead to misunderstandings, emotional distance, and even the breakdown of relationships. In romantic relationships, the lack of emotional intimacy can be particularly damaging, as partners may feel unsupported or disconnected.
Conclusion
Societal expectations of masculinity have a profound influence on men’s mental health, contributing to issues such as depression, anxiety, and substance abuse. The rigid norms surrounding masculinity—emphasizing emotional stoicism, self-reliance, and dominance—create significant barriers for men to express their feelings, seek help, and manage their mental health. These pressures result in emotional distress, which can manifest in destructive behaviors and a reluctance to seek support.
By challenging traditional notions of masculinity and encouraging a more inclusive and emotionally open understanding of gender, society can help reduce the negative impact of these expectations on men’s mental health. Redefining masculinity, providing mental health support, and addressing substance abuse with sensitivity to these gender norms are crucial steps in promoting the emotional well-being of men. Through these efforts, we can break the cycle of harm and create a healthier, more supportive environment for all individuals, regardless of gender.
Societal expectations of masculinity have far-reaching impacts on both individual men and society as a whole. These expectations contribute to emotional repression, isolation, and mental health issues such as depression, anxiety, and substance abuse among men. Furthermore, the societal pressure to conform to rigid gender roles perpetuates gender inequality, normalizes violence, and hinders progress in mental health awareness.
On an emotional level, these expectations have deep consequences, affecting men’s ability to express their emotions, seek help, and develop meaningful connections. The emotional toll of traditional masculinity—marked by stress, anxiety, depression, and substance abuse—reflects a profound need for cultural change. By redefining masculinity to allow for a wider range of emotional expression, vulnerability, and empathy, society can reduce the harmful effects of these expectations and promote healthier emotional lives for men.
SOURCES
Addis, M. E. (2008). Gender and depression in men. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 15(3), 153–168.
Betz, D. E., & Menon, M. E. (2021). Masculinity and mental health: How male gender roles influence mental health outcomes. Psychology of Men & Masculinities, 22(2), 159–170.
Bronson, M. A. (2018). The psychology of men and masculinity: New directions in research and practice. Psychology Press.
Mahalik, J. R., Burns, S. M., & Syzdek, M. (2007). Masculinity and perceived normative health behaviors as predictors of men’s health behaviors. Social Science & Medicine, 64(11), 2201–2209.
Levant, R. F. (2014). The new psychology of men. Psychology of Men & Masculinities, 15(2), 145–157.
McDermott, R. C., & Roos, J. G. (2020). Gendered stress and coping in men: Implications for mental health care. International Journal of Men’s Health, 19(3), 276–292.
Vogel, D. L., Heimerdinger-Edwards, S. R., Hammer, J. H., & Hubbard, A. (2011). “Boys don’t cry”: Examination of the links between masculine gender role conflict and mental health in men. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 58(3), 368–382.
Wetherell, M., & Edley, N. (1999). Negotiating masculinities: Imaginary voices, practices, and social relations. Discourse & Society, 10(3), 345–378.
Whitehead, S. M. (2002). Men and masculinities: Key themes and new directions. Polity Press.
Williams, M. T., & Emslie, C. (2014). Masculinity and mental health: A review of literature. Health Psychology Review, 8(2), 232–247.
HISTORY
Current Version
December, 12, 2024
Written By
BARIRA MEHMOOD
